What Happens If ADR Fails?

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Mediation & Collaboration

  • ADR does not have to resolve every issue to be worthwhile. You may still settle some disagreements and narrow the remaining issues.
  • You can adjust your negotiation strategy and continue working toward a resolution.
  • You may try another form of ADR, such as moving from Mediation to Arbitration when appropriate.
  • An arbitrator or judge can decide unresolved issues if you ultimately cannot reach an agreement.

If you are considering Mediation, Collaborative Divorce, or another form of Alternative Dispute Resolution (“ADR”), you may have one very reasonable concern: What happens if it doesn’t work?

You may worry that you’ll spend months negotiating, pay legal and professional fees, and eventually end up in court anyway. That can happen.

But an ADR process that doesn’t produce a complete settlement is not necessarily a failed process.

You May Still Resolve Some Issues

Divorce is rarely one single disagreement.

You may need to resolve parenting, child support, spousal support, property division, debt, the family home, pensions, and several smaller issues.

Suppose you enter Mediation with six unresolved questions and leave with agreements on five.

I wouldn’t call that a failure. You’ve substantially narrowed your dispute. You can then focus your time, money, and legal resources on the one issue that actually requires further attention.

Even if you eventually need someone else to decide that issue, you are in a much different position than if you had litigated everything from the beginning.

What Happens If Mediation Doesn’t Work?

In Mediation, the Mediator helps you negotiate but does not have the authority to impose a solution.

If you cannot reach an agreement, you have choices.

You might schedule another Mediation session after gathering additional information. You may consult your lawyers and return with different proposals. You might use Arbitration for a specific unresolved issue.

And yes, litigation remains available when necessary.

The important point is that trying Mediation does not mean you surrender your other options.

Collaborative Divorce Is Different

Collaborative Divorce has an important distinction.

You and your spouse sign a Participation Agreement committing to resolve your issues without litigation. Your collaboratively trained lawyers are part of that settlement process.

If you terminate the Collaborative process and decide to litigate, those lawyers cannot simply become your litigation lawyers.

You will need to retain new counsel.

That requirement is intentional. It ensures that everyone involved in the Collaborative process is genuinely committed to settlement rather than quietly preparing for court while negotiations are taking place.

Could You Try Another Form of ADR?

Absolutely. ADR is not one single process.

Maybe Mediation helped you identify the real dispute, but you now need an arbitrator to make a decision. Perhaps lawyer-assisted negotiation becomes more productive after you’ve narrowed the issues.

The process should serve the problem—not the other way around. That is why choosing the appropriate dispute resolution process at the beginning is so important.

When Is It Time to Go to Court?

Sometimes you’ve done everything reasonably possible and you still cannot reach an agreement.

One person may refuse to disclose financial information. Serious parenting or safety concerns may exist. Someone may simply refuse every reasonable proposal. At that point, litigation may become necessary.

Court is an essential part of our family justice system when you need it. But needing court for one difficult case doesn’t mean court should be your first choice.

ADR Isn’t About Guaranteeing Agreement

No Mediator, Collaborative Lawyer, or negotiation process can guarantee that two people will agree.

What ADR can give you is an opportunity to maintain control over your future.

You can exchange information, identify what actually matters, explore solutions, and potentially narrow the issues before giving decision-making authority to someone else.

And if ADR doesn’t produce a complete settlement?

You reassess. You determine what has been accomplished, identify what remains unresolved, and choose the next process that gives you the best chance of moving forward.

That isn’t failure. That’s problem-solving.


FAQs

1) Do you have to start your divorce over if Mediation fails?

No. You may still have agreements on some issues, useful financial disclosure, and a clearer understanding of what remains disputed. You can then determine the best process for resolving those remaining issues.

2) Can you go to court after trying ADR?

Depending on the ADR process, yes. Mediation does not prevent you from later pursuing litigation. Collaborative Divorce has different rules, including the requirement to retain new lawyers if you leave the Collaborative process and litigate.

3) Can you switch from Mediation to Arbitration?

Potentially, yes. If you cannot negotiate a particular issue, Arbitration may provide a way to obtain a decision outside the traditional court process. Your lawyer can help you determine whether that approach makes sense for your circumstances.

Pierre Boileau, K.C.

Pierre Boileau

+ posts

With over 35 years of practice Pierre Boileau, K.C. has gained experience as a Mediator, Collaborative Family Lawyer, Litigator and now as an Arbitrator. Pierre’s extensive experience has shown him that client satisfaction is maximized when clients have control over their own future. This can best be achieved through interest based negotiation. Only as a last resort, should litigation be considered. When necessary, Pierre relies upon his vast court experience and training.

Pierre remains committed to continuing to practice at a high level with particular care, interest,and sound judgment. He doesn’t shy away from particularly challenging cases. Pierre’s greatest reward comes from the satisfaction of assisting clients through one of the most challenging experiences of their lives.